How much do I love Dean Winchester?
Henriksen says, wonderingly, "I shot the sheriff ..."
And I say, "But you didn't shoot the deputy" -- because hey, he *didn't*, and because COME ON, how could you NOT say that, it was the perfect setup, *you* probably said it, too.
And then Dean said it!! With that little smirk, like he just couldn't resist it either. And I was very, very happy.